This episode of Big Blend Radio's "Supervision Matters" Podcast features leadership coach, HR consultant, and author Rita Sever with 13 practical tips for evaluations that are fair, specific, and genuinely helpful, the kind that build trust instead of dread. Whether you're a supervisor writing your first review or an employee wondering what to expect, Rita shows how an evaluation can be one more way to help people succeed.
Watch the episode below or listen to / download the audio on Podbean:
Key Conversation Highlights
Tip 1: Make the Tool and the Process Fair, and Seen as Fair — An official evaluation goes in someone's file, so Rita says the form, how it was developed, and what people are graded on should all make sense to the people being evaluated. In legal terms, both the process and the outcome need to be seen as fair, or the system and its results aren't trusted. Consistency matters just as much: managers (not HR) write the evaluations, so they need training in supervision and a shared understanding of what "needs improvement" or "on target" actually means.
Tip 2: Take Time for Preparation — Rita suggests that the supervisor and the staff member each prepare their own notes on strengths, challenges, and how things are going. Then comes a casual conversation to compare, followed by the official conversation about the written evaluation, where the employee can add a paragraph or two about anything they see differently, and both look ahead to goals for the next year. It underlines that this is about helping you succeed, not just handing out a report card.
Tip 3: Everything Must Be Job Related — Keep the job description handy while writing. When Rita read hundreds of evaluations as an HR director, the ones she sent back were often full of comments like "you're so nice." Friendliness counts when it's tied to the job, such as a customer relations value, but on its own it can look like a good grade because you like someone. She also cautions against holding approved leave, such as illness, injury, or bereavement, against someone's performance.
Tip 4: No Surprises — If a problem first shows up on the evaluation, Rita says the supervisor hasn't done their job. Concerns belong in conversations all year long. She recommends regular check-ins, at least monthly, that end with the question "Is there anything else we need to know?" so people feel safe bringing up anything, from a workload problem to a harassment concern. Silence is a bad sign, and she shares a past case where a single complaint opened the door to many more.
Tip 5: Don't Only Talk to Your Employees When There Are Problems — An evaluation is really a more serious feedback conversation, and feedback should cover what's working as well as what isn't, then agree on priorities going forward.
Tip 6: Focus on Strengths When Possible — People learn more and better when challenges are tied to a strength. You're great with customers, so let's bring that same attention to your coworkers. You're strong with data, and a relationship with your clients is what helps them hear it.
Tip 7: A Discussion, Not a Lecture — It's a guided, two-way conversation, not "here you go, read this, sign it off." Ask whether it makes sense, what they disagree with, and what the supervisor might have forgotten, like the star performer from six months ago who never got a mention.
Tip 8: Cover the Entire Time Period — Rushed supervisors often write from the last couple of months. Notes from regular meetings make it easy to cover the whole year and to see patterns over time, such as an issue that's been raised again and again. Rita also talks about roles that quietly change when someone picks up extra work with no adjustment in pay, hours, or training, and why the evaluation is a place for employees to speak up, or to say they'd like to try something new.
Tip 9: Frame Your Conversation to Be Effective — Rita sees a supervisor's role as setting people up for success, and she ties this tip to her JOIN feedback formula. Join means connecting with the person first, Observation describes what you actually saw or heard, Impact explains the effect, and Need states what you need going forward. Along the way, "no report carding" gets a laugh, and Rita says she should add it to her list.
Tip 10: Watch Out for Loaded Words — Words like "attitude," "professional," and "dependable" are generalizations that make people defensive and mean different things to different people. Rita's advice is to talk about the behavior, not your interpretation of it, such as "in our meetings you tend to be really negative when someone brings up a new idea." Even "professional" can carry different connotations depending on culture and language, so ask yourself what you really mean, be specific, and tie it to the job.
Tip 11: Be Objective and Fair — Don't compare employees ("I wish you acted more like Judy"); compare apples to apples, with consistency across the organization. Don't critique someone on work that isn't even their job, and keep personal things like political party out of an evaluation entirely.
Tip 12: Distinguish Between Style and Effectiveness — Just because someone does it differently doesn't mean it's wrong. Rita's questions: is it working, are they getting the results they need, and are they following procedures? Early-morning report writers or people who focus with headphones on are fine if the work gets done. Style becomes your business when it affects the team, like a last-minute approach that leaves everyone stressed.
Tip 13: Make It a Two-Way Evaluation — Rita's bonus tip is to ask your staff how your supervision is working for them and what they wish you would do differently. Sometimes the answer is as simple as a regular meeting that conflicts with a parent's family schedule, but people just didn't think they could say so. Small things left unsaid erode trust, and leaders shouldn't gossip about their employees, either.

Resources & Links
Visit Rita's website: supervisionmatters.com
Learn more about the JOIN formula in Rita's Giving Feedback episode
Read more in the Supervision Matters Digital Podcast Magazine
Listen to more episodes on the Supervision Matters Podcast page
Have a Question for Rita? Ask us on our Contact Page.